Gourmet Palette

The Sauce Is the Dish: The Secret of a Vinaigrette

The sauce is the dish. A vinaigrette whisked with a touch of mustard holds together without separating. Simmered long and slow, a tomato sauce concentrates the tomato's umami, and a gently softened onion changes the taste of a plate.

How do you make a vinaigrette that won’t separate?

Shaking the jar gives you an illusion of emulsion — one that never lasts

A vinaigrette that splits back into two layers happens to everyone, and it has nothing to do with luck. All it takes is one ingredient to bind the oil and the vinegar (most often a small touch of mustard), and the whole sauce changes character: it turns smoother, thicker, and holds together over time instead of falling apart before your eyes. That, at least, is how Martha Holmberg describes it, and it's an idea worth bearing in mind the next time you make a salad.

The technique matters just as much as the ingredient. Shaking the jar gives you an illusion of emulsion that never lasts: Holmberg prefers to whisk, and will even dip a battery-powered milk frother into the bowl for a few seconds to properly bind the two liquids together. You don’t need that exact tool to grasp the principle: whisk rather than shake, and your vinaigrette will stay silky right down to the last spoonful.

Why does a slow-simmered tomato sauce taste different?

When tomato sauce simmers gently on the heat for a long time, two things are happening quietly, Holmberg explains: the flesh breaks down and softens, while the water evaporates little by little. That slow loss of water concentrates the flavours, until the sauce no longer tastes like the tomato juice it started as, but something deeper and rounder.

That something is umami. As Holmberg points out, the tomato naturally carries this fifth taste, alongside sweet, salty, sour and bitter, thanks to its glutamic acid. Simmering doesn't invent it: it reveals it. Which is why a sauce given time to come into its own always has more to say than one that's been rushed.

And what does a slowly softened onion bring to the plate?

The third gesture is the most patient one: the onion. Martha Holmberg turns it into a sauce in its own right, a caramelised onion coulis, because its flavour is sweet and its texture silky and melting. On one condition she states plainly: give it time to caramelise slowly, and never let it brown too fast. A rushed onion stays sharp; an onion forgotten over low heat turns almost into jam.

Our tables have always known this: the softened onion that opens a marqa, coats a Sunday chicken or slips under a warm mechouia salad needs no recipe and no timer, only patience and a spoon to taste.

That, in the end, is what happens when you linger a little longer at the stove or over the salad bowl: you've taken the time to whisk, to simmer, to let the onion soften without ever rushing it. You don't measure that patience in minutes: you taste it on the spoon.

Also on La Sultane

Artichoke Meatballs

7 Little Gourmet Cravings Every Tunisian Has!

Lemon Cheesecake with Orange Coulis

Couscous with Ouzef Pesto, Anchovies and Fines Herbes

Frequently asked questions

How do you make a vinaigrette that doesn’t separate?
Simply add an ingredient that binds the oil and vinegar together, most often a touch of mustard, to get a smooth, thick sauce that holds up over time. Technique matters too: it's better to whisk than to shake the jar, since shaking only produces an illusory emulsion that doesn't last.
Why does my vinaigrette separate into two layers?
It happens to everyone, and it's not a matter of luck: without a binding ingredient like mustard, the oil and vinegar won't stay combined, and the sauce settles back into two layers.
Why does a tomato sauce that simmers for a long time taste better?
During a long simmer, the flesh breaks down and softens while the water evaporates little by little, which concentrates the flavours. The sauce then no longer tastes like the tomato juice it started out as, but something deeper and rounder.
What is umami in a tomato sauce?
It's a fifth taste, alongside sweet, salty, sour and bitter, which the tomato carries naturally thanks to its glutamic acid. Simmering doesn't create this flavour: it reveals it by concentrating the sauce.
Should you whisk or shake a vinaigrette?
It’s better to whisk: shaking the jar only produces an emulsion that doesn’t last, whereas whisking properly binds the oil and vinegar and keeps the vinaigrette silky right down to the last spoonful.
Health & Serenity

A flat stomach in just 7 days

A flat stomach comes with healthy eating and regular exercise. No drink, however natural, replaces those two. Here is a banana recipe.

September 4, 2020

The letter to our readers

The best of La Sultane, once a week: ideas and society, economy and ecology, culture and the art of living.

Your address is used only to send you the letter. One-click unsubscribe in every issue. Learn more about your data

← Back to section